Charles Edward Stuart
Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)
called the PRETENDER, grandson of James II., King of England, son of James Edward and Clementina, daughter of Prince Sobieski, was born in Rome, Dec. 31, 1720. In 1742 he went to Paris and persuaded Louis XV. to assist him in an attempt to recover the throne of his ancestors. Fifteen thousand men were on the point of sailing from Dunkirk, when the English admiral, Norris, dispersed the whole fleet. Charles now determined to trust to his own exertions. Accompanied by seven officers he landed on the W. coast of Scotland, from a small ship called the "Doutelle." Many Lowland nobles and Highland chiefs went over to his party. With a small army thuş captured med he marched forward, formed Perth, then Edinburgh, Sept. 17, 1745, defeated an army of 4,000 0 British under Sir John Cope at Prestonpans, Prestonpans, Sept. 22, and advancing obtained possession of Carlisle. He now caused his father to be proclaimed king, and himself regent of England; removed his headquarters to Manchester, and soon found himself within 100 miles of London, where many of his friends awaited his arrival. The rapid successes of the adventurer now caused a part of the British forces in Germany to be recalled. Want of support, disunion, and jealousy among the adherents of the house of Stuart, some errors, and the superior force opposed to him, compelled Prince Charles to retire in the beginning of 1746. The victory at Falkirk, Jan. 28, 1746, was his last. As a final attempt he risked the battle of Culloden against the Duke of Cumberland, April 16, 1746, in which his army was defeated and entirely dispersed. The prince now wandered about for a long time through the wilds of Scotland, often without food, and the price of £30,000 sterling was set upon his head. At length, on Sept. 20, 1746, five months after the defeat of Culloden, he escaped in a French frigate. He received a pension of 200,000 livres yearly from France, and of 12,000 doubloons from Spain. Forced to leave France by the terms of the Peace of Aix-la-Chapelle (1748), he went to Italy, and in 1772 married a princess of Stolberg-Gedern, from whom eight years later he was separated. He died Jan. 31, 1788, and was buried at Frascati. The funeral service was performed by his only surviving brother, the Cardinal of York, with whose death in 1807 the Stuart line ended.
What Has Changed in the Last Century
The narrative Collier's set out in 1921 is still the one historians tell: the landing from the Du Teillay (the "Doutelle" of older accounts), Prestonpans, the march to Derby, Culloden on 16 April 1746, the £30,000 on his head, and death in Rome in 1788. What has shifted is the framing. Where Collier's calls him "the Pretender" and "the adventurer", modern writing treats the 1745 rising as a serious European and British civil conflict rather than a romantic escapade, and stresses the brutality of the government reprisals in the Highlands after Culloden, which the 1921 entry passes over entirely. The battlefield itself is now a National Trust for Scotland site, surveyed archaeologically and given a visitor centre in 2007. And while the Stuart male line did end with Cardinal York in 1807, the Jacobite claim is now traced onward by genealogists through Savoy to the Dukes of Bavaria.
Written for this edition, 2026.