The Meta-Encyclopedia

Ethnology

Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)

the science which treats of various races of mankind and their origin. With anthropology, philology, psychology, and sociology it helps to cover the complete study of man. Ethnologists rely, in their different schemes of classification, on what are called ethnical criteria. These criteria are partly internal, the skeleton in general, and particularly the cranium; partly external, color of skin, color and texture of hair, and such other determining elements, whether physical or mental, as may be studied on the living subject. Of mental or intellectual criteria immeasurably the most important is language. Different phonetic systems often involve different anatomical structure of the vocal organs. The most eminent naturalists mainly agree in classifying the whole human family in three, four, or at most five fundamental divisions; but the term fundamental is to be understood in a relative sense, for all races are necessarily regarded as belonging to a common primeval stock, constituting a single species though not sprung from a single human pair. Rather has the growth been the slow evolution of a whole anthropoid group spread over a more or less extensive geographical area, in a warm or genial climate, where the disappearance of an original hairy coat would be a relief. The difficulty of determining the exact number of these types is due to the fact, pointed out by Blumenbach, that none of them are found in what may be called ideal perfection, but that all tend to merge by imperceptible degrees in each other. They are the black, frizzly-haired Ethiopic (negro); the yellow lank-haired Mongolic; the white, smooth-haired Caucasic; the coppery, lank and long-haired American, and the brown, straight-haired Malayo Polynesian. The last is commonly rejected as evidently the outcome of a comparatively recent mixture in which the Mongolic elements predominate. Most authorities regard also the American as a remote branch of the same group; this view seems justified by the striking Mongolic features occurring in every part of the New World, as among the Utahs of the Western States and the Botocudos of eastern Brazil. The character of hair and color of skin has been used by Huxley as the basis of his classification, which divides mankind into Ulotrichi, crisp or woolly-haired people with yellow or black skin, comprising Negroes, Bushmen, and Malays; and Leiotrichi, smooth-haired people, sub-divided into Australoid, Mongoloid, Xanthochroic (fair whites), and Melanachroic (dark whites) groups. Peschel's classification, based on a number of different particulars, such as the shape of the skull, the color of the skin, the nature and color of the hair, the shape of the features, etc., is as Australians, Papuans, the Mongoloid nations, the Dravidians (aborigines gines of India), Hottentots, and Bushmen, Negroes, and the Mediterrean nations. The Ethiopic group falls naturally into a Western or African and an Eastern or Oceanic division. The Western occupies all Africa from the Sahara S. and comprise a N. or Sudanese branch (African Negroes proper), and a S. or Bantu branch (more or less mixed Negro and Negroid populations). The Oceanic division of the Ethiopic group comprises four branches: (1) the Papuans of the Eastern Archipelago and New Guinea; (2) the closely allied Melanesians of the Solomon, New Hebrides, New Caledonia, Loyalty, and Fiji Archipelagoes; (3) the now extinct Tasmanians, and Tasmanians, and (4) the Australians, the most divergent of all Negro or Negroid peoples. The Mongolic group occupies the greater part of the Eastern hemisphere and till the discovery of America was in exclusive possession of the New World. Its chief branches are (1) the Mongolo- Tartars of central and north Asia, Asia Minor, parts of Russia and the Balkan Peninsula; (2) the Tibeto-Indo-Chinese of Tibet, China proper, Japan, and Indo- China; (3) the Finno-Ugrians of Finland, Lapland, Esthonia, Middle Volga, Ural Mountains, north Siberia, Hungary; (4) the Malayo-Polynesians of the Malay Peninsula, the greater and lesser Sunda Islands, Madagascar, the Philippines, Formosa, and eastern Polynesia; (5) the American Indians, comprising all the aborigines of the New World, except the Eskimo, who with the Ainos of Yesso, form aberrant members of the Mongolic group. The Caucasic group, called also Mediterranean because its original domain is western Asia, Europe and north Africa -i. e., the lands encircling the Mediter- Basin-has in recent times ranean spread over the whole of the New World, south Africa, and Australasia. The chief branches (1) Aryans of are: India, Iran, Armenia, Asia Minor, and great part of Europe, with sub-branches; (2) Semites of Mesopotamia, Syria, Arabia, and north Africa, with subbranches; (3) Hamites of north and east Africa; (4) the Caucasians proper; (5) the Basques of the western Pyrenees. MT. ETNA, SICILY

What Has Changed in the Last Century

Collier's in 1921 defined ethnology as the sorting of mankind into three to five "fundamental divisions" by skull shape, skin colour and hair texture, and even suggested that "different phonetic systems often involve different anatomical structure of the vocal organs." Almost none of that survives. Genetics has shown that human variation is continuous and that the great majority of it lies within any single population rather than between the supposed races — a result associated with Richard Lewontin's analysis of 1972 and confirmed repeatedly since the Human Genome Project — while fossil and DNA evidence places the origin of all living humans in Africa within the last few hundred thousand years. The word "ethnology" itself has largely given way to cultural and biological anthropology, and the racial taxonomies of Blumenbach, Huxley and Peschel are now studied as history rather than used as science; the entry's claim that the Tasmanians were "now extinct" is also wrong, as an Aboriginal Tasmanian community continues today.

Written for this edition, 2026.