The Meta-Encyclopedia

Excommunication

Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)

a word denoting exclusion, whether temporary or permanent, from fellowship in religious rites, involving also, where participation in such rites is required in the civil order, privation of the rights of citizenship. It is not peculiar to the Biblical religions, but is found in most of the sytematized cults, whatever their origin. The clearest analogy, however, to the Christian discipline of excommunication is that furnished by the Rabbinical code. The offender first received a public admonition, and seven days later, if he did not make satisfaction, the lesser excommunication, Niddui, was pronounced against him, whereby he was isolated during 30 days from contact with all save his wife and children, being obliged to keep at least four cubits' distance from all others; and though the sentence did not technically include expulsion from the synagogue, yet this provision practically enforced it. At the expiration of 30 days, a second term of like duration was enjoined in case of continued impenitence; and the contumacious were then visited with the greater excommunication of Cherem, which excluded both from the synagogue and from all social intercourse, and the offender was treated as a leper. These two grades of excommunication were the only ones anciently in use; but the later rabbins added a third and severer one, styled Shammatha or Anathe ma Maranatha, which was lifelong, at tended with solemn imprecations, and sometimes entailing forfeiture of goods. The Christian system of excommunication is based doctrinally on the precept of Christ (Matt. xviii: 15-18) and on the precepts and practice of St. Paul. It was primarily, as the word wor denotes, exclusion from communion in the eucharist and the agape, or love-feast, including also suspension from office in the case of clerical offenders; and it was distinguished as major and minor, each having various degrees of severity. The most notable exercise of the power of excommunication in the modern Anglican Church was when Bishop Gray, as of Cape Town, deprived Metropolitan Metropolitan and excommunicated Bishop Colenso of Natal in 1863, which sentence, approved by the Convocations of Canterbury and York, the General Convention of the American Episcopal Church, the Episcopal Synod of Scotland, and the Provincial Council of Canada, was reversed by the Judicial Committee of Privy- Council in 1865. In the Established and other Presbyterian Churches of Scotland, the lesser excommunication, involving deprivation of all "sealing ordinances," can be pronounced by the kirk session. Islam forms an exception to the almost universal incidence of the practice of excommunication. Under the Moslem code every religious offense carries with it a temporal penalty, such as fines, scourging, stoning, or other mode of death, and only in this last manner can an offender be cut off from the congrega. tion.

What Has Changed in the Last Century

When Collier's wrote this in 1921, excommunication was described as still carrying civil weight where church rites underpinned citizenship; that link has since vanished almost everywhere, and the penalty is now purely spiritual. Catholic practice was reordered by the 1983 Code of Canon Law, which cut the number of offences and dropped the old class of excommunicati vitandi, the shunned whom other Catholics had to avoid "leper" fashion, so that today's excommunicate is barred from the sacraments but not from social contact. The most publicised modern cases have been Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and the four bishops he consecrated without papal mandate in 1988, whose excommunications Benedict XVI remitted in 2009. Perhaps the most symbolic change came in December 1965, when Paul VI and the Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras jointly consigned the mutual anathemas of 1054 to oblivion; the Jewish cherem the article describes at length has meanwhile become very rare, and the Amsterdam community has repeatedly declined to lift its 1656 ban on Spinoza.

Written for this edition, 2026.