The Meta-Encyclopedia

Indian Summer

2 of the 6 encyclopedias on this shelf carry an entry for Indian Summer. Both are reproduced below, so you can see where they agree and where they differ.

Aiton's Encyclopedia (1910)

in the United States and Canada, a name applied by general consent to a hazy, smoky, warm spell of weather expected late in autumn. The cold weather which precedes Indian summer is called squaw winter. So far as the origin can be traced, the term appears to have arisen in western Pennsylvania about 1790, but the exact origin is not known. In the West the term is supposed to indicate the season when the Indian went hunting for buffalo and other game to lay in his winter's meat. The Dakota Indians, at least, counted on a time of this sort along in October and November when fine hunting weather might be expected. Whatever its origin, the term is now well set in literature. A line or two from Lowell's An Indian Summer Reverie is expressive of the season's rare beauty: What visionary tints the year puts on, When falling leaves falter through motionless air Or numbly cling and shiver to be gone! How shimmer the low flats and pastures bare. How fuse and mix, with what unfelt degrees, Clasped by the faint horizon's languid arms, Each into each, the hazy distances! The softened season all the landscape charms; Those hills, my native village that embay, In waves of dreamier purple roll away, And floating in mirage seem all the glimmering farms. From gold to gray Our mild, sweet day Of Indian summer fades too soon; But tenderly Above the sea Hangs, white and calm, the hunter's moon. In its pale fire The village spire Shows like the zodiac's spectral lance; The painted walls Whereon it falls Transfigured stand in marble trance! --John Greenleaf Whittier.

Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)

the name given to a period which generally occurs towards the end of mild summer weather of autumn in the United States.

What Has Changed in the Last Century

Aiton's guess in 1910 that the phrase arose in western Pennsylvania about 1790 has been pushed back: the earliest recorded use generally cited is from the 1770s, in a letter by the French-American writer St John de Crevecoeur, and the origin is still unsettled. The definition has also been tightened, the US National Weather Service treating Indian summer as a spell of warm, hazy, calm weather after the first killing frost, rather than any mild autumn stretch as Collier's loosely had it in 1921. The term has spread far beyond North America, largely displacing the older English names St Luke's summer and St Martin's summer. The companion term Aiton's gives for the cold snap before it, squaw winter, has dropped out of use because squaw is now recognised as a slur, and some broadcasters now prefer second summer to Indian summer for the same reason.

Written for this edition, 2026.