The Meta-Encyclopedia

Mantis

2 of the 6 encyclopedias on this shelf carry an entry for Mantis. Both are reproduced below, so you can see where they agree and where they differ.

Aiton's Encyclopedia (1910)

or Praying Mantis, man'tis, an insect allied to the grasshopper and the cricket. It has a slender body with long, locust-like hind legs and oval wings. The front legs are stout and spiny, well fitted to seize and hold the insects on which it feeds. When at rest it has a curious habit of raising the front part of its body and holding its front legs up before its vicious face, as if in prayer. "Certainly they are pious-looking fellows," says Comstock, "with their front legs clasped together in front of their meek, alert faces, and it is no wonder that they are called praying mantes. But the only prayer that could ever enter the mind of a mantis would be that some unwary insect might come near enough for him to grab it with his hypocritical claws, and so get a meal." There are several species. The American mantis is found only in the Southern States, where it is called the rear-horse and mule-killer. In Europe it is known as the camel-cricket. The praying mantes are fierce fighters, fencing with their arms like hussars. The Chinese keep them in joints of bamboo. They let them out and pit them against each other like gamecocks, often betting small sums on the result. The Arab holds that the mantis prays with its face turned toward Mecca. The mantis lays its eggs in oval-shaped masses on the stem of a plant, covering them with silk having a curiously braided appearance. See Insect; Grasshopper

Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)

the so-called soothsayer, or praying insect; the typical genus of the family Mantidæ. Two species occur in southern Europe: M. religiosa, from two to two and a half inches in length, and M. oratoria, a smaller species. Others are found in the warmer regions of the world.

What Has Changed in the Last Century

Aiton's put the mantis "allied to the grasshopper and the cricket" in 1910; today mantises have their own order, Mantodea, of some 2,400 species, and their nearest relatives are cockroaches and termites, a grouping (Dictyoptera) that molecular studies have since confirmed. The claim that "the American mantis is found only in the Southern States" was already going out of date as it was printed: the Chinese mantis, accidentally introduced near Philadelphia in the 1890s, and the European Mantis religiosa spread widely across the northern United States and Canada, and their egg cases are now sold commercially to gardeners as biological control. The rest holds up well: high-speed photography has confirmed how fast those "hypocritical claws" strike, and Comstock's verdict on the prayer remains the scientific one. Sexual cannibalism, unmentioned in either account, has become the most studied thing about the insect, and is now known to occur in the wild and not only in laboratory cages.

Written for this edition, 2026.