The Meta-Encyclopedia

Marsyas

2 of the 7 encyclopedias on this shelf carry an entry for Marsyas. Both are reproduced below, so you can see where they agree and where they differ.

Aiton's Encyclopedia (1910)

mar'si-as, in Greek legend, a Phrygian flute player defeated in a musical contest by Apollo. The goddess Athene had invented the flute and played upon it herself. One day Cupid laughed at her countenance distorted by the action of blowing. Athene went to a still pool, put her flute to her lips and looking into the clear water, saw Cupid had cause for laughter. She threw away her flute in a pet, pronouncing a curse upon anyone who should play on it. Marsyas found it. He was delighted with the sweet sounds it produced, and practised until he dared challenge Apollo to a contest. The Muses were the umpires. Apollo played the lyre, but was not able to win the victory until he united his voice to the music of his instrument. Then he was declared victor, and, according to the terms of the contest, could do what he pleased with his opponent. He bound Marsyas to a tree and flayed him alive.

1000 Classical Characters (1900)

A celebrated piper of Celaene in Phrygia. He challenged Apollo to a trial of skill in music, which challenge was accepted, the Muses being appointed umpires. The palm of victory was awarded to Apollo, who tied his antagonist to a tree and flayed him. Martialis, Marcus Valerius. A native of Spain who came to Rome when he was about twenty years old, where he became noticeable for his poetical genius. Martial wrote fourteen books of epigrams, and died in the seventyfifth year of his age. 2026 Editor's Note: The instrument Marsyas played was the aulos , a double-reed pipe, not a modern flute. As punishment for his hubris in challenging the god, Apollo had Marsyas flayed alive. (Ed: BR 2026-06-14)