Reciprocity
Collier's New Encyclopedia (1921)
a policy under which there exist two sets of tariff duties; one to be put in force under ordinary circumstances; the other a much lower one to be established in case another country reduces its tariff schedules to a corresponding scale. In the case of the United States reciprocity has been greatly talked of as existing between that nation and Canada. In 1854 a reciprocity treaty was negotiated between the two countries which provided for mutual free trade between the United States and Canada. While it was popular at first in stimulating trade the business depression in the United States in 1857 greatly influenced that nation to repeal the act in 1865. The Republican party a few years later, in order to please the agricultural and exporting classes who were in general opposed to the high tariff, championed the principle of reciprocity. In 1875 a reciprocity treaty was negotiated and signed between Hawaii and the United States, but it was not until the McKinley Administration that such treaties were made with any important nations. During that administration reciprocity was established with France, Portugal, Germany, and Italy. Treaties were negotiated with other countries which the Senate refused to ratify. President McKinley in his last public address, the Buffalo Exposition speech, strongly advocated reciprocity. In 1903 a reciprocity treaty with Cuba was negotiated and ratified by the Senate. In 1911 President Taft negotiated a reciprocity treaty with Canada and in spite of the opposition of many of the Western members of his party he succeeded in securing its passage by Conto pronouns of this class. As a noun, gress, only to have it rejected by Canthat which is reciprocal to another thing. ada. The Democrats, believing as they do in low tariff duties, have never espoused reciprocity, holding that the reciprocal action of another country is immaterial.
What Has Changed in the Last Century
Collier's wrote in 1921 that reciprocity meant two tariff schedules, and that the Democrats "have never espoused reciprocity." Within a generation the parties had swapped places: Cordell Hull, a Democrat, pushed through the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934, which let the President cut duties by up to half in bilateral bargains, and that machinery led to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade in 1947 and the World Trade Organization in 1995, where concessions are generalized to all members rather than traded pair by pair. The Canadian reciprocity that Taft lost in 1911 finally arrived in the Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement of 1989, widened into NAFTA in 1994 and replaced by the USMCA in 2020. The word itself has faded from the tariff vocabulary, though the older bargaining instinct returned in the trade disputes and tariff rounds of recent years.
Written for this edition, 2026.